Site Meter Food History » Blog Archive » Melbourne Bread and Butter Pudding

Melbourne Bread and Butter Pudding

by Gillian Polack

The Melbourne version of bread and butter pudding is about the same age as yesterday’s. The differences in ingredients are all due to religious differences - the bread used pushed the pudding in a particular direction and the ingredients of the bread and butter pudding were modified to match this. It’s a really cool example of a simple difference creating a dish that tastes quite distinct.

Both family recipes are attested to the nineteenth century though they were preserved orally, which means that as tastes and availability of ingredients change, the recipe may have been modified. Today’s version is from my rather Jewish family (is it possible to be ‘rather Jewish?). The big difference between the Palmer pud and the Polack pud is that until recently the Polacks made our pudding on Sunday using leftover challah. This means that the whole dish is richer and messier. Challah is a plaited egg-bread eaten on Sabbath - dairy free but quite rich.

Slice leftover challah and place in a dish, sprinkling raisins generously through the layered bread. Add the same sort of custard as normal bread and butter pudding - the only differences are that the sugar can be reduced a little and you add two pinches of cinnamon. Sprinkle nutmeg and cinnamon on top of the pudding then bake. Serve with rich cream and a big pot of tea mid-afternoon on a really lazy Sunday.

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to Food History. It's Free!

One Response to “Melbourne Bread and Butter Pudding”

  1. Food History » Blog Archive » Recipes for the Intrepid, c 1908 Says:

    [...] Hardtack Pudding. (The Bread Pudding of the [...]

Leave a Reply


About Food History

A few herbs, a pinch of spice and foods of the past create your perfect foodie recipe at Food History. Expand your palate with everything from hot scones to hot websites without leaving your computer. At Food History there's a gourmet’s delight of food, health, history, and an amazing side of mushrooms. From holiday food customs to any number of fabulous recipes, you can find out anything and everything about your favorite tasty tidbits.

Food History Author(s)
    » Gillian-Polack

Food, Cooking & Wine Channel Posts

  • This Week's Wine Menu is All About Fleet Week
    This week’s theme: history and tidbits Complimentary Tasting 2006 Roussanne, Fess Parker Vineyard, Santa Barbara $25 Picture yourself in San Diego in 1935, for the very first Fleet [...]
  • Cocktails – tasting notes and final list
    The cocktails for the Banquet were: Gernsbackian Dream - a copacetic martini style drink, the cat's pyjamas Southern Nights Julep– Mint, champagne and fruit, iced to perfection, a julep [...]
  • Fall foods
    I know that we're well into October and the weather has been on the chilly side. But I've still been in denial about it being fall. This CSA share is proof that it's summer no more. Two heads [...]
  • Last of the Conflux food (but not the summer wine?)
    This is another dish we didn't use but which the testers loved. Leg of lamb, Boulangère. Season a leg of lamb with salt and pepper, and rub with garlic and butter. Put in roasting pan with a [...]
  • Happy Conflux recipes
    The sherbet or sorbet was another dish that the chef used his background for. He had done a Titanic menu previously and is perfectly familiar with the palate cleansing sorbet of the period, so [...]
  • Peel it, Juice it and Eat it....the Pomegranate
    The pomegranate has a brilliant colored red juice and the seeds, that are colored the same amazing red, can stain a lot of clothing and even your favorite apron. The tiny little sack that hold a [...]
  • Be an Artist of Wine
    Next Wednesday--one week from tonight--will be the last wine seminar of the year at Rosenblum Cellars, hosted by yours truly. The Art of Blending will take place from 6:30 to 8:30pm at the winery [...]
  • More recipes!
    Canapes – there were so many delicious canapé recipes to choose from and they all tested well. I chose simple ones that met everyone's dietary requirements. BLACK OLIVES Pit black olives, [...]
  • Limited Edition Snickers Dark Mix
    I am always up to giving something labeled dark chocolate a try even though so many times I end up disappointed with it tasting too much like milk chocolate. Usually just a look at the [...]
  • Cooking with Beef
    • Beef, Vegetable and Noodle Skillet Serves: 6 1 pkg. shells and cheese dinner 1 lb. extra lean ground beef 1/2 cup Italian dressing 1 bag frozen veggie blend, thawed 1 tsp. dried basil [...]

Hot Off The Press