Site Meter Food History » Blog Archive » Suet vs Butter - a Christmas story

Suet vs Butter - a Christmas story

by

dscn0189.jpg

When people tell a group “Merry Christmas everyone” I always have to bite my tongue to avoid adding “And well over the Fast.” It’s because Christmas is very closely linked to New Year in general Aussie culture and of course, one of the new years in my branch of Aussie culture is followed by a fast. This is pure culture confusion added to a little mild frustration that the person giving such generous wishes kind of forgets that not all of us share Christmas.

This would normally be the start of a big grouch. It isn’t. It’s the start of a bit of food history wonderment.

My Jewish self was invited (as a friend) into two different families for Christmas this year. For the last few years I’ve been included in the celebrations of my friend Lesley, but this year James (age 11 ½ ) invited me to his celebrations as well. Since his mother is one of my close friends, this made for a very happy yesterday and my Christmasses with Lesley and her family are always wonderful.

What was super-special this year was that a whole list of food history questions lined up in a row and were answered. I won’t give you all the questions and answers now – they will appear when they’re ready, but you need to know that you can’t get all your food history from books. How a dinner is served, what the regular jokes are, what ingredients are silently substituted – so many answers that can be best got from primary sources.

Dinner with family is the best primary source for current practices. It also answers other questions.

One answer I’ll give you tonight. It’s related to suet.

Last night Donna made Christmas pudding from scratch, according to her favourite recipe. Like quite a few modern Australian recipes for Christmas pudding, it was butter based. I can now say absolutely that butter does not substitute for suet. They may or may not give different textures (Donna’s pud was finished differently to the suet ones I tested, so that wasn’t comparable) but butter gives a buttery underlay to the pudding, entirely different in mouthfeel and overall taste to the suet. This doesn’t mean you can’t replace suet with butter. It does mean you need to realise that when you make that replacement, it’s not the same recipe any more.

I hope everyone who celebrated Christmas enjoyed it. I hope you all enjoyed my series of posts of festive recipes. Now we’re back to normal. In January we’ll have some special guests posting, though, so don’t get too used to normalcy.

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to Food History. It's Free!

Leave a Reply


About Food History

A few herbs, a pinch of spice and foods of the past create your perfect foodie recipe at Food History. Expand your palate with everything from hot scones to hot websites without leaving your computer. At Food History there's a gourmet’s delight of food, health, history, and an amazing side of mushrooms. From holiday food customs to any number of fabulous recipes, you can find out anything and everything about your favorite tasty tidbits.

Food History Author(s)

Food, Cooking & Wine Channel Posts

  • Pancakes - or not
    Tomorrow is Shrove Tuesday. I know this because very year around this time I try to persuade friends to collect me throws from Mardi Gras parades. Some years I succeed, this year I didn't. I [...]
  • Great dinners: Stress relief through cooking
    [caption id="attachment_493" align="alignnone" width="1024" caption="Abstraction: Ability to move beyond photo by Mary MacIntyre"][/caption] At this time of night, I ought to geeting ready for my [...]
  • Sunday Evening Cookie Making
    • Shortbread Cookies Makes: 2 dozen 1-1/2 cup butter, softened 1 cup granulated sugar 1/2 tsp. salt 6 egg yolks 2 tsp. vanilla extract 4 cups all-purpose flour In a large bowl, cream [...]
  • 2 Women Changing their local garden community
    [caption id="attachment_489" align="alignnone" width="1024" caption="Congratulations:Garden more!"][/caption] This a fantastic way to start farms across the nation! In our own backyards! [...]
  • Food we eat:Dr. Vandana Shiva - Part 1
    [caption id="attachment_486" align="alignnone" width="1024" caption="Real food for all species"][/caption] "Half the people in the world don't get the nutrition they need" paraphrased from Dr [...]
  • What's for Dinner Tonight?
    • Turkey, Black Bean and Corn Salad Wraps Serves: 4 Shred some cooked turkey and mix with 1 cup of corn, 1 cup of black beans and 3 cups shredded romaine lettuce. Mix that with 1 cup salsa [...]
  • Ways to a Healthier Heart
    February is heart health month and the best way to get your heart healthy is to practice a few heart health exercises and to adopt a strategy to keep your heart at it's best. Here is some ways right [...]
  • We met the chef
    I'm still a hothouse of minor ailments, but I really want to give you a banquet update because there's so much news. There are a hundred recipes being tested over the next ten days. I need to [...]
  • Have you had a Fig Lately?
    Did you know that many people when they go to purchase fruits, don't consider buying figs as a part of their fruit bowl, and you maybe one of those people. There are 150 Varieties of figs the [...]
  • Time out with the letter 'p'
    Today you have a miserable excuse for a post. I came down with something last night and today I still have that something, plus I had proofs to look at. Working through illness is seldom wise, so [...]

Hot Off The Press