Site Meter Food History » Blog Archive » Where Gillian rants (sorry)

Where Gillian rants (sorry)

by Gillian Polack

bigsandwich_xenia.jpg

One of the commenters on this blog, Neil, has hit upon a really crucial definitional question in his comment on one of those posts where I try to puzzle out the balance between retaining a cuisine and maintaining kashruth. You can find his comment here.

Neil implies that all Jewish cooking must be kosher. He says that my grandmother’s cooking was “non-jewish cooking done by a non-observant (or the kashrut laws) jew�. Except that Jewish cooking isn’t just a matter of eating bacon or not eating bacon, of mixing milk and meat or not mixing milk and meat.

Is my mother’s cooking less Jewish than one of her granddaughter’s, because that close relative is Ultra-Orthodox and is stricter than my mother, who is only very kosher Orthodox? They both have different dishes and sinks and my youngest sister doesn’t. Yet that sister is the one who keeps the family foodways by handing the cooking down to the next generation and by bringing the family together for traditional dinners and by playing a leading role in her synagogue.

The ‘Jewish’ bit of the foodways is deceptive. It’s easy to say that religious law is the same as foodways. That any Jew who doesn’t keep very strictly kosher is not actually following Jewish foodways, no matter how strong their family traditions have been over time. In any culture that has strong religious foundations and strong food cultures, for some people foodways and religious laws will be very close and for other people foodways and recipes and family customs are quite a long distance from religious laws.

The dishes I puzzle about can’t just be compared to the rules in the Shulchan Aruch (a late codifcation of Jewish law) and be given a Jewish culture pass or fail mark. They have to be taken in the context of their their own time and place. My grandmother lived in the middle of a vibrant Jewish community where very, very few people kept kosher as did her ancestors. Her foodways – as I’m about to demonstrate for a conference in Sydney next month – are very typical of her ancestry and her place. They’re typical of much English Jewry as well from the first half of the nineteenth century. It is Anglo-Jewish cooking. All the early Anglo-Jewish cookbooks contain bits of bacon.

Judaism more than most religions has porous boundaries where culture and foodways and religion are concerned. Many cultures have similar distinctions, though. What the priest says to do as opposed to what the community actually does (study the theory of Medieval marriage as opposed to the practice and you might be amused). What the rabbi teaches (halacha) as opposed to what actually happens in the home.

I suspect I will argue forever that my grandmother cooked in a way that fitted the Jewish culture of her time. I would not be so silly as to claim there were religiously sound reasons for this, but nor would I be so dismissive of Jewish cultures other than that of my Ultra-Orthodox family members to assume that they are not Jewish, simply because they follow different aspects of halacha.

Anglo-Australian Jewish cooking is not the same as modern Australian Jewish cooking, or as Romaniot Jewish cooking or Israeli Jewish cooking. I should blog more varieties of Jewish cooking and show you some of the variants, I guess. Except there’s so much else to talk about! What you need to know is that they’re all culturally Jewish – and some of them are more religiously proper than others. This means that while lots of cuisines are culturally Jewish some of them are quite a way from the religious laws.

PS Sorry for evil joke in the picture. Hamburgers with cheese are also a problem for most Jews.

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to Food History. It's Free!

One Response to “Where Gillian rants (sorry)”

  1. Laura Goodin Says:

    If a Jew cooks, it’s Jewish cooking, as far as I can see it.

    – Laura “I’m Catholic, I can has cheezburger” Goodin

Leave a Reply


About Food History

A few herbs, a pinch of spice and foods of the past create your perfect foodie recipe at Food History. Expand your palate with everything from hot scones to hot websites without leaving your computer. At Food History there's a gourmet’s delight of food, health, history, and an amazing side of mushrooms. From holiday food customs to any number of fabulous recipes, you can find out anything and everything about your favorite tasty tidbits.

Food History Author(s)
    » Gillian-Polack

Food, Cooking & Wine Channel Posts

  • Christmas Cookies
    Are you ready for the most wonderful time of the year? My favorite Christmas food has to be cookies! It seems that this is the only time of the year we make these wonderful sweet treats, so I gobble [...]
  • the month ahead
    I've taken a day off from blogging to line up some goodies for you. There will be guest bloggers. And they have interesting things to say. I'll introduce them as they appear, but I thought I'd let [...]
  • Slow Cooker Mashed Potatoes
    Ordinarily I make mashed potatoes the old fashioned way on the stove top. But this year (since I wasn’t pregnant and could be thankful for the bounty of wine) I decided to prepare just about [...]
  • Limited Edition Junior Mints Inside Outs
    Yesterday at Target I found Limited Edition Junior Mint Inside Outs in the holiday candy section. I have heard about these before and I think they originally came out as limited editions over 3 [...]
  • Holiday Hershey's Chocolate Kisses
    Yesterday at Target I picked up the four different holiday flavors of Kisses. They were not on sale, but I am planning to make some holiday kisses with them and did not feel like waiting to see [...]
  • Food and thunder
    Summer came in last night with a mutter of thunder. It's been gently storming for a few days and I kept forgetting (because I was too busy muttering imprecations against the weather) that I [...]
  • How about Chili and a Sandwich
    Yogurt-Curry Chicken Sandwich Makes: 4 sandwiches 1/3 cup plain yogurt 2 tbs. sweetened flaked coconut 1 tbs. green onion, chopped 1 tsp. curry powder 1/4 tsp. salt 2 cups cooked chicken, [...]
  • Quick Salads
    • Turkey and Wild Rice Salad Serves: 5 6 oz. pkg. long grain and wild rice mix 1/2 cup raisins 1/2 cup celery, thinly sliced 2 tbs. red onion, finely chopped 2 green onions think sliced 3 [...]
  • Distiguishing the Cuts of Meat
    • Filet Mignon: Should be tender meat and carved from a good cut of tenderloin. It should appear lightly marbled without a lot of white throughout the red/pink meat. • Boneless Strip [...]
  • Being Jewish, eating Ham, and the vexed question of Christmas trees
    I was going to give you a lard or ham recipe from The Neighborhood Cook Book, but the heart has gone out of me. I had the annual "Why aren't you putting up a Christmas tree this Sunday?" [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Monthly Love and Relationship Forecast: Beth Speaks
    December 2, 2008 My Mercury and Venus in Capricorn got ambitious and decided to make a video for the folks over at Starlinked. My Aquarian Sun said "cool!" and my Pisces Moon went "Oh gawd, help!" [...]
  • Leona Lewis' Bleeding Love is 2008's Best Selling Single
    What a year it has been for singer Leona Lewis who got started with her career after winning The XFactor talent contest, the British equivalent of American Idol . According to iTunes, the sultry [...]
  • Nice Article
    [caption id="attachment_665" align="alignleft" width="200" caption="Photo from Bicycling Magazine"][/caption] Here's a little article on Shemar Moore's bike riding quests - he rides to raise money [...]
  • Bookmark these Coupon Sites!
    You've searched and you've searched and you can't find the best coupon site there is. With your holiday gift giving list piling up, coupon shopping matters today more than any other time. So, we're [...]
  • Austin 2008 Guide to Christmas Tree Farms
    Now that Thanksgiving is over many of you will begin preparing for Christmas. Big on the list of "things to do" is finding the perfect Christmas tree. As you know, I'm all about "real" Christmas [...]
  • A new world order arising
    When President George Bush, the Elder, declared his intention to create a new world order, he had to back away quickly and never mentioned the phrase again. Not only did he sound like the [...]
  • The Night Before Christmas (skeptic's version)
    Okay … gotta ‘fess up here: I first produced this little piece a few years ago … but, considerin’ all that’s goin’ on here in the ‘08, I thought it’d be apro … apropri … cool to [...]
  • Playhouse Disney's Handy Manny Meets Flicker Week
    I know Playhouse Disney's Handy Manny Meets Flicker Week began yesterday, but I did not find out until yesterday morning because the Disney website calendar does not update until the first of the [...]
  • Hate Planet Green, But Love Bill Nye
    If you were not already aware of it, there is a high-numbered cable channel called Planet Green.  It is part of the Discovery family of cable channels, and I have to say it is the least fav of all [...]
  • Don Diamont Leaving The Young & the Restless
    Soap Opera Digest is reporting that Don Diamont (Brad) has been let go from The Young & the Restless. As of right now there is no word as to when his last day is. I am sad to see that Diamont [...]